• changsmith2


* * * (out of four)

“Blow the Man Down” is what you might call an “elliptical” movie: Plot points pass with very little fanfare -- often a terribly brief scene or an unheralded visual cue -- and the film consistently refuses to Spell Things Out; you really have to pay attention.

Since the new Amazon original is a thriller with a dandy double-murder plot, this approach is quite effective for folks willing to put in the effort; we are forced to invest intensely in the tale -- like we’re working synergistically with the writers to help flesh out and fill in their story.

Aiding involvement is the fact that one of the murders is a total mystery, while we know exactly what happened with the other. That latter killing was perpetrated by the younger of two sisters struggling to make ends meet in a Maine fishing village. Ditsy, drunk and more than a little freaked out, Mary Beth killed a man who began to get too aggressive after picking her up at a bar. (Her state of mind was undoubtedly affected by the gun in his glove compartment -- and bloodstains in the trunk of his car.)

The girl then confesses to her older, more sensible sibling, whereupon the two manage to dispose of the body -- but not very tidily, I’m afraid. Next morning, local police ask to borrow the girls’ skiff to retrieve a body; but it turns out that is a totally different corpse.

So … are the murders related? Is either connected to Enid Devlin, who runs the local brothel and doesn’t seem to treat her ladies very well? And what about the $50,000 Mary Beth found when she returned to the crime scene to look for a left-behind weapon?

Though “Blow the Man Down” has been billed as a black comedy, it isn’t really very funny. Yet it somewhat earns this moniker by maintaining a sardonic distance from its lurid goings-on. In part, this is achieved through the film-makers’ light touch -- as in the elliptical plotting, and the way the camera cuts away at the more horrid moments. Several online reviewers compared it to a Coen brothers movie -- specifically “Fargo”; and that will give you a fair idea of how writer-directors Danielle Crudy and Bridget Savage Cole proceed. Their mild ironic tone is established in the first scene, when a bunch of hard-working fishermen belt out an old sea-chanty -- sort of like a seaside Greek chorus; and these maritime music-makers reappear several times thereafter.

Acting is excellent in every single role, supported by strong music, handsome photography and atmospheric production design; you can almost smell the ocean and the fresh-caught fish.

If the film seems a bit slow or laconic, well -- give them some time to blow the man down.

Or the woman.

“Blow the Man Down,”

directed by Bridget Savage Cole & Danielle Crudy

Run time: 91 min.

Rated R for language and some violence


Recent Posts

See All


Lycoming Critic’s Corner, June 2020 (for ON THE PULSE website) One reason Lycoming Critic’s Corner loves movies is their power to heal: to make us think; to challenge assumptions and biases; to hold o


  • Facebook Social Icon
  • Twitter Social Icon
  • Instagram Social Icon

© 2017 by Joseph W. Smith III. Proudly created with